Skip to content
Study Hall
Lesson 2 of 6Writing for Reconciliation
Unit 5 · Lesson 2 of 6

Meaningful Allyship in Reading, Writing and Speaking

What allyship looks like when it is a practice rather than a label: listening first, amplifying without speaking over, avoiding tokenism and performative gestures, and writing about communities you do not belong to with accuracy and care.

6 min read8 practice questionsAsk AI about this →

Key things to remember

  1. 1Allyship is judged by consistent action — listening, learning on your own, amplifying with credit, and accepting correction — not by self-description.
  2. 2Speaking up challenges harm and directs attention to Indigenous voices; speaking over replaces those voices with your own.
  3. 3Tokenism includes a person or text to be counted rather than heard; performative allyship is a gesture that stands in for action.
  4. 4Name the specific nation, community or author; avoid 'Indigenous people believe' and possessives such as 'our' or 'Canada's'.
  5. 5Use Inuit for the people and Inuk for one person; capitalize Indigenous, First Nations, Métis, Elder and Survivor.

Being an ally is not something you announce; it is something other people can see you doing, consistently, when it is inconvenient. In an English course that practice shows up in very ordinary places — which authors you read, how you phrase a sentence about a nation you are not part of, what you do when a classmate repeats a stereotype, and whether your presentation quotes Indigenous writers or only writers about them. None of it requires perfection. It requires listening, checking, and being willing to be corrected.

Allyship is a practice, not a title

  • Listen before you speak. Read and hear First Nations, Métis and Inuit people describing their own experiences before forming a view about them.
  • Do your own learning. Do not expect an Indigenous classmate to explain history, answer for their nation, or educate the room. That is work you can do with the reports, books and organizations available to everyone.
  • Amplify, and credit. Share, quote and cite the people who said something first. Passing on an Indigenous writer's argument under your own name — even in paraphrase — takes the credit away from them.
  • Accept correction without defensiveness. If someone tells you a term or a claim is wrong, the useful response is to thank them, fix it, and not make the conversation about your feelings.
  • Be consistent. Allyship that appears only on September 30, or only when someone is watching, is a performance. It is measured by what you do the rest of the year.
Speaking overSpeaking up / amplifyingTells the story for themTakes the platformor the creditDecides what a community“really” needsCorrects people abouttheir own experienceCentres their own feelingsPasses the mic;shares the platformCredits and citesIndigenous voicesFollows the community’s leadChallenges stereotypesamong peersAccepts correction andkeeps learningListenLearnAmplifyCheck backlistening loopThe loop moves you from the left column to the right.Allyship is a practice, not a label.
Fig 1Speaking up challenges harm in your own circles and points toward Indigenous voices; speaking over replaces those voices with yours.
ASpeaking up
  • Challenging a stereotype when a friend or classmate repeats it
  • Pointing people to what Indigenous authors and organizations have said
  • Using your turn in a discussion to raise a perspective that is missing, and naming whose it is
  • Asking whether the people affected were consulted before a plan goes ahead
  • Stepping back so someone with lived experience can take the space
BSpeaking over
  • Retelling an Indigenous person's experience as though it were your insight
  • Explaining a nation's culture to its own members
  • Centring your guilt or feelings until the discussion becomes about you
  • Claiming to speak 'for' a community you are not part of
  • Interrupting or correcting someone about their own history

Tokenism and performative gestures

GestureWhen it becomes performativeWhat makes it meaningful
Land acknowledgementRead quickly from a script, with the nations' names mispronounced and nothing following itLearning the specific nations and treaties of the place, saying why you are acknowledging them, and connecting it to an action
Wearing orange on September 30The shirt is the whole of the effort, and the photo is the goalLearning a Survivor's published account, reading Call 80, and supporting Survivor-led organizations
One Indigenous text on a reading listIt is there so the list can be counted as diverse, and it is read as representing all Indigenous peoplesSeveral texts across nations, forms and time periods, each read on its own terms
A social media postIt replaces action and is quickly forgottenIt shares an Indigenous creator's own work, with credit, alongside something you actually did
Inviting an Indigenous speakerThey are asked to speak for everyone, are not paid for their time, or are there to make an event look inclusiveTheir expertise is respected, protocols are followed, their time is compensated, and they choose what they share
The test for tokenism: is the person or text there to be counted, or there to be heard?
Avoid pan-Indigenous generalizations
First Nations, Inuit and Métis are three distinct groups of peoples, and within them are many nations with their own languages, governance, histories and stories. A sentence that begins 'Indigenous people believe...' is almost always too broad to be true. Name the nation, community or author you are actually drawing on — 'in this Haudenosaunee story', 'the Métis author argues', 'Inuit Tapiriit Kanatami states' — and your claim becomes both more accurate and easier to support with evidence.

Writing about communities you do not belong to

  • Use the names people use for themselves. Nations have names in their own languages, and many publish their preferred spelling. Check the nation's or organization's own website.
  • Drop the possessive. 'Our Indigenous peoples' or 'Canada's Indigenous peoples' frames sovereign nations as belonging to the country. Write 'Indigenous peoples in Canada' or name the nation.
  • Capitalize as a mark of respect — Indigenous, First Nations, Inuit, Métis, Elder, Knowledge Keeper, Survivor — as recommended in Elements of Indigenous Style by Gregory Younging.
  • Watch the past tense. Writing that Indigenous peoples 'used to' hunt, speak their languages or hold ceremonies erases living communities. Cultures change and continue; write about them in the present where that is accurate.
  • Balance harm with agency. A text that describes only suffering tells half the story. Include resistance, resurgence, leadership and joy where your sources show them.
  • Do not retell stories that are not yours to tell. Some stories and teachings belong to particular families, clans or nations, and some are shared only in certain settings or seasons. Refer to published versions and credit the teller rather than rewriting them.
  • Say where you stand. In reflective or personal writing, it can be honest and useful to note your own relationship to the topic — for example, that you are a non-Indigenous reader learning from these texts.
Instead ofWriteWhy
'Eskimo'Inuit (plural), Inuk (one person)Inuit is the name Inuit use for themselves; the older term was imposed from outside
'Canada's Indigenous peoples'Indigenous peoples in Canada, or the specific nationRemoves the implication that nations are owned by the state
'Native legends' or 'myths'The nation's name plus stories, teachings or oral histories'Legend' and 'myth' imply the content is untrue or quaint
'Indian' outside a legal or historical contextFirst Nations, or the specific nation'Indian' remains a legal term under the Indian Act, but is outdated as a general description
'The Indigenous perspective'Name whose perspective: the author, the nation, the organizationThere is no single Indigenous perspective to speak of
1ExploreAsk questionsWhat do I think I know?Where did I learn it?Who is being shown?2DeconstructTake it apartWhose perspective is this?What is missing or silent?Who benefits from it?3ReconstructRebuild itCentre self-told voicesBe specific and currentLet people define themselvesA new representation raises new questions — so the cycle begins again.
Fig 2Explore a representation, deconstruct the assumptions inside it, then reconstruct understanding from voices of the people represented.

The same three moves help you respond to texts that present colonialist or inaccurate images of Indigenous peoples. Explore the representation: who made it, when, for what audience, and where it has travelled. Deconstruct it: what assumptions does it carry — that Indigenous peoples are vanishing, all alike, or stuck in the past? Whose voice is absent? What harm has that image done, for example in how people are treated or which policies seemed reasonable? Reconstruct your understanding by turning to First Nations, Métis and Inuit authors, artists and organizations who represent themselves, and let your writing be built from their work.

Worked examples

Reveal one step at a time and try to beat it to the next line.

Example 1
Revise this sentence from a draft: 'Our Native people used to live in harmony with nature, and their legends teach us to respect the earth.'
Example 2
Your group is presenting on the work of an Inuit organization. No one in the group is Inuk. Plan the presentation responsibly.
Example 3
In a group discussion, a classmate says, 'Indigenous people get everything for free.' Respond by speaking up without speaking over.

Where marks get lost

  • Writing 'Indigenous people believe...' as if many distinct nations shared one set of beliefs.
  • Using 'our Indigenous peoples' or 'Canada's First Nations', which frames nations as belonging to the country.
  • Asking the one Indigenous student in the room to explain their culture or respond on behalf of all Indigenous peoples.
  • Writing about Indigenous cultures entirely in the past tense, as though they no longer exist.
  • Treating a land acknowledgement or an orange shirt as the entire contribution, with no learning or action behind it.

Flashcards 8

Allyship
Speaking up vs speaking over
Tokenism
Performative allyship
+ 4 more

Practice

1
Which action is an example of speaking over rather than speaking up?
2
Why is the phrase 'Canada's Indigenous peoples' a problem?
3
What is the word for one Inuit person?
4
Match each phrase to the better choice.
'Eskimo'
'Native legends'
'Our Indigenous peoples'
'The Indigenous perspective'
'They used to hold ceremonies'
5
Which is most clearly tokenism?
6
What term describes a visible gesture of support that substitutes for real action?
7
Order the steps for responding to a colonialist representation in a text.
  1. 1Reconstruct understanding from First Nations, Métis or Inuit sources who represent themselves
  2. 2Consider the harm the representation has done
  3. 3Deconstruct its assumptions and whose voice is absent
  4. 4Notice the representation and describe it accurately
  5. 5Explore who made it, when, and for what audience
8
A sentence in your essay begins, 'Indigenous people believe that...'. What is the best revision strategy?

Spot a mistake on this page? Let us know