Skip to content
Study Hall
Lesson 5 of 5Molecular Genetics
Unit 3 · Lesson 5 of 5

Biotechnology and Its Issues

Restriction enzymes, ligase and plasmids for making recombinant DNA; gel electrophoresis, PCR, Sanger sequencing and DNA fingerprinting; cloning, transgenic organisms, gene therapy and CRISPR; and the legal, regulatory and ethical questions these raise in Canada and elsewhere.

11 min read12 practice questionsAsk AI about this →

Key things to remember

  1. 1EcoRI cuts 5'-GAATTC-3' between G and A on each strand, leaving complementary AATT sticky ends; DNA ligase seals the sugar-phosphate backbone.
  2. 2Recombinant DNA: cut gene and plasmid with the same enzyme, ligate, transform bacteria, and select on antibiotic agar.
  3. 3Gel electrophoresis: DNA (negative) moves toward the positive electrode; smaller fragments travel farther.
  4. 4PCR: denature about 95 °C, anneal about 55–65 °C, extend about 72 °C with Taq polymerase; copies .
  5. 5Cutting a linear molecule at sites gives fragments; cutting a circular plasmid at sites gives fragments.
  6. 6Canada: higher life forms not patentable (Harvard mouse, 2002) but patented genes in plants are enforceable (Schmeiser, 2004); human cloning banned (AHRA, 2004); genetic discrimination banned (GNDA, 2017); GM labelling voluntary (EU: mandatory above 0.9%).

Since 1982, people with diabetes have been able to inject human insulin made by bacteria. Before that, insulin was purified from the pancreases of cattle and pigs, the approach developed at the University of Toronto in 1921–1922 by Frederick Banting, Charles Best, James Collip and John Macleod, and some patients reacted to the animal protein. Making insulin in bacteria was possible because the genetic code is nearly universal: give E. coli a human gene with the right control sequences, and it makes the human protein. Biotechnology is the use of living things and their molecules to make products or solve problems, and modern genetic technology rests on a small toolkit: enzymes that cut DNA at exact sequences, an enzyme that glues DNA, carriers that move DNA into cells, and methods to copy, sort and read DNA. The same tools raise real questions. Who can own a modified organism? Should GM foods carry labels? Who may see your genetic information? This topic covers the tools first, then the issues.

Cutting and pasting DNA

Restriction enzymes (restriction endonucleases) are bacterial enzymes that cut DNA at specific recognition sites, usually 4–8 base pairs long. In nature they defend bacteria by chopping up the DNA of invading viruses; the bacterium protects its own DNA by adding methyl groups to its own recognition sites. Most recognition sites are palindromes: the sequence reads the same 5'→3' on both strands. EcoRI (from E. coli) recognizes 5'-GAATTC-3' and cuts between the G and the A on each strand. Because the two cuts are offset, each piece is left with a short single-stranded overhang, 5'-AATT, called a sticky end. Sticky ends made by the same enzyme are complementary, so any two pieces cut with that enzyme can base-pair with each other. Other enzymes, such as SmaI (which cuts CCC|GGG), cut straight across both strands and leave blunt ends with no overhang; blunt ends can be joined, but less efficiently. DNA ligase then forms phosphodiester bonds to seal the sugar-phosphate backbones, permanently joining the pieces. In a random sequence, any particular 6-base site appears on average once every base pairs, so a six-base cutter such as EcoRI makes fragments a few thousand base pairs long.

EcoRI cuts between G and A on each strand of its palindromic site, leaving complementary single-stranded AATT sticky ends.

To make recombinant DNA (DNA that combines sequences from different sources), the gene of interest and a vector are cut with the same restriction enzyme. A common vector is a plasmid, a small circular DNA molecule that bacteria copy independently of their chromosome. A cloning plasmid has an origin of replication, a site for the restriction enzyme, and a selectable marker such as a gene for resistance to the antibiotic ampicillin. The cut gene and cut plasmid are mixed so their sticky ends pair, and ligase seals them. Bacteria are then transformed: treated with calcium chloride and a brief heat shock (or an electric pulse) so that some take up plasmids. Only a small fraction succeed, so the bacteria are spread on agar containing ampicillin. Cells without a plasmid die, and only transformed cells grow into colonies. For human insulin, the gene used is a copy made from the insulin mRNA with the enzyme reverse transcriptase, called complementary DNA (cDNA). This matters because bacteria cannot splice out introns, and cDNA made from mature mRNA has none. The transformed bacteria are grown in large fermentation tanks, and the insulin is purified.

Recombinant DNA: making human insulin in bacteria1Cut both DNAs with the same enzyme (EcoRI)insulin gene (cDNA)EcoRI siteshuman DNAampRplasmid(1 EcoRI site)Same enzyme → both pieces get matching sticky ends.2EcoRI cuts GAATTC, leaving sticky ends5′3′3′5′GAATTCCTTAAGcuts betweenG and A onboth strands5′ ···3′ ···GCTTAAAATTCG··· 3′··· 5′sticky ends = single-stranded 5′-AATT overhangs3Mix: complementary sticky ends base-pairampRinsulin genesticky endsticky endopened plasmidAATT pairs with TTAA by H-bonds; nicks remain in the backbone4DNA ligase seals the backboneampRligaseligaserecombinantplasmidphosphodiester bonds close both nicks5Transform bacteria; select on ampicillinE. coli takes upthe plasmidagar + ampicillinonly cells carrying ampR (the plasmid) form colonies6Bacteria express the gene: human insulintranscription+ translationhuman insulin(A + B chains, S–S)universal genetic code: bacteria read the human gene
Fig 1Making recombinant DNA: cut the gene and plasmid with the same restriction enzyme, join the sticky ends with ligase, transform bacteria, and select transformed cells on antibiotic agar.

Separating, copying and reading DNA

Gel electrophoresis separates DNA fragments by size. Samples are loaded into wells at one end of a slab of agarose gel, which sits in a buffer between two electrodes. DNA is negatively charged because of its phosphate groups, so when the current is on, every fragment moves toward the positive electrode; the wells are placed at the negative end. The gel is a tangled mesh of fibres: short fragments slip through easily and travel farther, while long fragments are held back. Every DNA molecule has the same charge per unit length, so size is the only thing that decides how far a fragment moves. A DNA ladder, a mixture of fragments of known sizes, runs in one lane as a ruler. Afterward the gel is stained with a dye that glows under UV or blue light. Each visible band is millions of copies of fragments of one size.

Gel electrophoresis: DNA fingerprint− negative electrode (cathode, black lead) — wells end+ positive electrode (anode, red lead)LadderCrime sceneSuspect 1Suspect 2Suspect 310 000 bp5000 bp3000 bp2000 bp1000 bp500 bpwellsmatchmatchDNA is negative(phosphate groups),so it moves towardthe + electrode.Smaller fragmentstravel fartherthrough the gel.Read sizes againstthe ladder (distance≈ linear in log size).Suspect 2 matchesthe crime-scenesample: all bands.
Fig 2Gel electrophoresis: DNA runs from the wells (negative end) toward the positive electrode, and the smallest fragments travel farthest. The ladder lane gives sizes for comparison.

The polymerase chain reaction (PCR), invented by Kary Mullis in 1983, copies a chosen stretch of DNA billions of times in a few hours. The tube holds the template DNA, two short DNA primers that flank the target sequence, all four nucleotides (dNTPs), and Taq polymerase, a heat-stable DNA polymerase from Thermus aquaticus, a bacterium from hot springs. A thermal cycler repeats three steps: denaturation at about 95 °C separates the strands; annealing at about 55–65 °C lets the primers pair with their target sequences; extension at about 72 °C lets Taq build new strands from the primers. Each cycle doubles the number of copies, so after cycles ; 30 cycles turn one molecule into about . Sanger sequencing (1977) reads the order of bases. A polymerase copies the template in the presence of a small amount of dideoxynucleotides (ddNTPs), which lack the 3'-OH needed to add the next nucleotide, so a strand stops wherever one is added. The result is a set of fragments ending at every position, each end tagged with a colour for its base; sorted by size, they spell out the sequence. DNA fingerprinting compares short tandem repeats (STRs), places where a 2–6 base sequence is repeated back to back a number of times that varies between people. PCR copies about 20 STR loci, and the combined pattern is so variable that the chance of two unrelated people matching is far below one in a billion. Canada's National DNA Data Bank, run by the RCMP since 2000, stores STR profiles, and DNA evidence helped overturn the wrongful convictions of Guy Paul Morin (1995) and David Milgaard (1997).

Applications

ApplicationHow it worksExample
Reproductive cloning (somatic cell nuclear transfer)The nucleus of a body cell is transferred into an egg whose own nucleus has been removed. An electric pulse starts division, and the embryo is implanted in a surrogate mother. The offspring is a genetic copy of the nucleus donor (except for mitochondrial DNA, which comes from the egg).Dolly the sheep, born in 1996 at the Roslin Institute in Scotland, cloned from an adult mammary gland cell. It took 277 attempts.
Transgenic cropsA gene from another species is inserted to give the plant a new trait.Bt corn carries a gene from the bacterium Bacillus thuringiensis for a protein toxic to certain insect larvae such as the European corn borer. Canola was bred in Canada in the 1970s; herbicide-tolerant GM canola now makes up about 95% of Canada's canola crop.
Transgenic animalsA gene is added to a fertilized egg so every cell of the animal carries it.AquAdvantage salmon: Atlantic salmon with a growth-hormone gene from Chinook salmon, switched on by a promoter from the ocean pout, so it grows year-round and reaches market size faster. Health Canada approved it as food in 2016, the first GM animal approved for food in Canada.
Gene therapyA working copy of a gene is delivered into a patient's cells, usually by a modified virus, to treat a disease caused by a faulty gene. Somatic gene therapy affects only the patient; germ-line changes would be inherited.Approved treatments exist for an inherited form of blindness and for spinal muscular atrophy.
CRISPR-Cas9 gene editingA guide RNA matching the target sequence leads the Cas9 enzyme to that spot, where it cuts both strands. The cell's repair then disables the gene or inserts a supplied sequence.Adapted from a bacterial immune system by Jennifer Doudna and Emmanuelle Charpentier (Nobel Prize in Chemistry, 2020). The first approved CRISPR therapy, for sickle-cell disease, arrived in 2023.
Human Genome ProjectAn international effort (1990–2003) to sequence the roughly 3 billion base pairs of the human genome.Found only about 20 000 protein-coding genes; a fully complete (telomere-to-telomere) sequence followed in 2022. Cheap sequencing now supports personalized medicine.
The same toolkit (restriction enzymes, vectors, PCR, sequencing) underlies all of these applications.

Issues: law, regulation and ethics

Case, law or agencyWhat it decided or does
Harvard College v. Canada (Supreme Court of Canada, 2002)Harvard sought a patent on the oncomouse, a mouse modified to be prone to cancer for research. The Court ruled 5–4 that higher life forms such as plants and animals are not patentable "inventions" under the Patent Act, although the process used to make the mouse could be patented. The United States and Europe had granted patents on the mouse.
Monsanto Canada v. Schmeiser (Supreme Court of Canada, 2004)Saskatchewan farmer Percy Schmeiser saved and planted canola seed containing Monsanto's patented herbicide-tolerance gene without a licence. The Court ruled 5–4 that the patent on the modified gene and cells was valid and that growing the plants was "use" of the invention, so he had infringed it. He did not have to pay damages, because he had not profited from the trait (he had not sprayed the herbicide).
Health CanadaAssesses the safety of novel foods, including GM foods, before they can be sold (for example, checking for new allergens or changed nutrition).
Canadian Food Inspection Agency (CFIA)Regulates "plants with novel traits", including the environmental release of GM crops, and livestock feeds.
Environment and Climate Change CanadaWith Health Canada, assesses the environmental and health risks of new living organisms, such as GM fish or microbes, under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act (CEPA).
Assisted Human Reproduction Act (2004)Makes it a crime to create a human clone for any purpose, which includes reproductive cloning, and to alter the human genome in a way that could be passed to descendants.
Genetic Non-Discrimination Act (2017)Makes it illegal to require a person to take a genetic test, or reveal test results, as a condition of providing goods, services or a contract such as insurance; adds genetic characteristics to the Canadian Human Rights Act. The Supreme Court of Canada upheld it in 2020.
Key Canadian court decisions, laws and regulators for biotechnology.
ACanada
  • Regulates by product: any plant with a novel trait is assessed, whether it came from genetic engineering, chemical mutagenesis or conventional breeding
  • GM food labelling is voluntary (a national standard sets the rules); labels are mandatory only for health or safety changes such as a new allergen or altered nutrition
  • Many GM crops approved and widely grown (canola, corn, soybeans, sugar beets)
  • Higher life forms cannot be patented (Harvard mouse), but modified genes and cells can (Schmeiser)
BEuropean Union
  • Regulates by process: organisms made by genetic engineering go through a separate, stricter approval system
  • Mandatory labelling of foods containing more than 0.9% GM material
  • Very few GM crops grown commercially; member states may ban cultivation on their territory
  • Transgenic animals such as the oncomouse can be patented if an ethics test finds the benefit outweighs animal suffering
IssueArguments in favourConcerns raised
GM crops and foodHigher yields, less insecticide spraying (Bt crops), crops that tolerate drought or disease, better nutrition (Golden Rice with provitamin A). Approved GM foods pass safety assessment.Herbicide-resistant weeds and insect resistance from heavy use; genes spreading to wild relatives or organic farms; seed supply controlled by a few companies; consumers' right to know what they eat.
Patenting life formsPatents reward expensive research, encourage investment, and require inventors to publish their methods.Living things are not human inventions; farmers' traditional practice of saving seed; patents can limit research access.
Cloning and gene editingResearch into disease, conserving endangered species, therapies that could cure inherited disorders.Low success rates and animal welfare in cloning; safety of changes that could be inherited; future generations cannot consent; fears of "designer babies".
Genetic informationPersonalized medicine, early diagnosis, forensic identification, reuniting families.Discrimination by insurers or employers; privacy of relatives who share your DNA; security and consent for DNA databases.
Scientists, farmers, companies, ethicists and consumers weigh these differently; a strong analysis uses evidence and acknowledges trade-offs.

Worked examples

Reveal one step at a time and try to beat it to the next line.

Example 1
A linear 10.0 kb DNA molecule has EcoRI sites 2.0, 5.5 and 8.0 kb from its left end. It is cut completely and run on a gel. How many fragments form, what are their sizes, how many bands appear, and which band is farthest from the wells?
Example 2
A 5.4 kb plasmid has a single EcoRI site. A 1.2 kb gene cut out with EcoRI is inserted into it. (a) How large is the recombinant plasmid? (b) What does a gel show if the original plasmid, and then the recombinant plasmid, are each cut with EcoRI?
Example 3
A PCR starts with 50 copies of a target sequence. (a) Assuming perfect doubling, how many copies are there after 25 cycles? (b) Starting from a single copy, what is the smallest number of cycles needed to reach at least one billion copies?
Example 4
Should Canada require mandatory labelling of GM foods, as the European Union does? Outline a balanced analysis.

Where marks get lost

  • Saying DNA moves toward the negative electrode, or that larger fragments travel farther. DNA is negative (phosphate groups) and runs toward the positive electrode, and the smallest fragments move farthest.
  • Counting fragments for a plasmid as if it were linear. Cutting a circle at k sites gives k fragments, not k + 1.
  • Using 2 × n instead of for PCR. The copies double every cycle, so 10 cycles multiply the DNA by , not by 20.
  • Cutting the gene and the plasmid with different enzymes whose sticky ends do not match. The ends must be complementary for the pieces to pair before ligase seals them.
  • Stating that Canada bans all patents on GM organisms. The Harvard mouse ruling stopped patents on the animal itself, but the Schmeiser ruling confirmed that patents on modified genes and cells are valid, even inside a plant.

Flashcards 10

Restriction enzyme
Sticky ends vs blunt ends
Plasmid vector
Transformation
+ 6 more

Practice

1
A linear DNA molecule has 3 recognition sites for a restriction enzyme. How many fragments form when it is cut completely?
fragments
2
A circular plasmid has 4 recognition sites for a restriction enzyme. How many fragments form when it is cut completely?
fragments
3
A PCR starts with 20 copies of a target sequence. Assuming perfect doubling, how many copies are present after 15 cycles?
copies
4
The restriction enzyme HaeIII recognizes the 4-base site GGCC. In a random DNA sequence, on average how many base pairs apart are its sites?
bp
5
Four DNA fragments are run on an agarose gel. Which ends up closest to the positive electrode?
6
Put the steps for producing human insulin in bacteria in order.
  1. 1Grow the bacteria on ampicillin agar to select transformed cells
  2. 2Transform E. coli with the recombinant plasmids
  3. 3Grow the selected bacteria in large tanks and purify the insulin
  4. 4Make cDNA of the insulin gene from its mRNA using reverse transcriptase
  5. 5Cut the cDNA and the plasmid with the same restriction enzyme
  6. 6Mix them so the sticky ends pair, then seal with DNA ligase
7
Match each tool or technique to its purpose.
PCR
Gel electrophoresis
Restriction enzyme
DNA ligase
Sanger sequencing
CRISPR-Cas9
8
Why is Taq polymerase used in PCR instead of human DNA polymerase?
9
Which 2017 Canadian law makes it illegal to require someone to take a genetic test or disclose the results in order to get insurance or other services?
10
What did the Supreme Court of Canada decide in Harvard College v. Canada (2002)?
11
How does Canada's approach to GM food labelling differ from the European Union's?
12
At three STR loci, crime-scene DNA has repeat numbers (8, 11), (14, 14) and (6, 9). Suspect A has (8, 11), (14, 15), (6, 9). Suspect B has (8, 11), (14, 14), (6, 9). Suspect C has (7, 11), (14, 14), (6, 9). Which suspect's profile matches?

Spot a mistake on this page? Let us know