Skip to content
Study Hall
Lesson 3 of 8Chemical Reactions
Unit 2 · Lesson 3 of 8

Evidence of Chemical Change and Conservation of Mass

How to tell a chemical change from a physical one using five kinds of evidence and gas tests, the vocabulary of reactants and products, and why mass is always conserved even when a balance seems to say otherwise.

4 min read9 practice questionsAsk AI about this →

Key things to remember

  1. 1A chemical change produces new substances; a physical change does not.
  2. 2Evidence of chemical change: colour change, gas produced, precipitate formed, energy (heat or light) given off or absorbed, new odour.
  3. 3Gas tests: hydrogen pops with a burning splint, oxygen relights a glowing splint, carbon dioxide turns limewater milky.
  4. 4Law of conservation of mass: total mass of reactants = total mass of products.
  5. 5Mass seems to change only in open systems, when a gas escapes or is taken in from the air.

A bike left out all winter grows rust. Cake batter goes into the oven runny and comes out spongy. A sparkler throws off light and heat until nothing is left but a grey wire. In each case the substances you started with have turned into new substances with new properties. That is a chemical change, or chemical reaction. Chemists cannot watch atoms rearranging, so they rely on clues they can see, hear, feel and smell, and then confirm with tests. This lesson covers those clues and one of the most important laws in chemistry: in a reaction, mass is never created or destroyed.

Physical change or chemical change?

APhysical change
  • The substance stays the same; only its form, size or state changes
  • Examples: ice melting, sugar dissolving, paper being cut, water boiling
  • Often easy to reverse (freeze the water again, evaporate the solution)
  • No new substance, so the particles themselves are unchanged
BChemical change
  • One or more new substances form, with different properties
  • Examples: wood burning, iron rusting, an egg cooking, baking soda fizzing in vinegar
  • Usually hard to reverse
  • Atoms are rearranged: old bonds break and new bonds form

Five kinds of evidence

Clues that a chemical change has happenedcolour changee.g. iron rustinggas (bubbles)e.g. baking soda+ vinegarprecipitatetwo solutionsform a solidheat or lighte.g. burningnew odoure.g. food spoilingClues, not proof: physical changes can show some of these too (boiling makes bubbles).The evidence is strongest when several clues appear together.
Fig 1Five mini-scenes showing evidence of a chemical change: a colour change, a gas produced as bubbles, a precipitate forming, an energy change as heat or light, and a new odour. Physical changes can show some of these too (boiling makes bubbles), so the evidence is strongest when several appear together.
EvidenceChemical change exampleA physical change that can fool you
Colour changeA copper roof turning green; a cut apple browningAdding food colouring to water
Gas produced (bubbles)Baking soda fizzing in vinegarWater boiling; a soft drink going flat
Precipitate (a solid forming in a liquid)Two clear solutions mixing to make a cloudy yellow solidCrystals forming as a hot salt solution cools
Energy released or absorbed (heat, light)A burning candle; a chemical hand warmer heating upA light bulb glowing; a cold pack cooling as its salt dissolves
New odourFood spoiling; a match being struckPerfume evaporating across a room
Each clue suggests a chemical change, but each one can also happen in a physical change.
Clues, not proof
No single observation proves a reaction happened. Bubbles from boiling water are still water. The strongest case has several kinds of evidence at once, and the best confirmation is a test showing that a new substance with new properties is present. A precipitate is a solid that forms when two solutions are mixed and settles or makes the mixture cloudy.
  • Hydrogen gas: a burning splint held at the mouth of the test tube makes a squeaky "pop".
  • Oxygen gas: a glowing splint (just blown out) bursts back into flame.
  • Carbon dioxide gas: bubbled through limewater (calcium hydroxide solution), it turns the limewater milky. It also puts out a burning splint, but so do several other gases, so the limewater test is the confirming one.

Reactants, products and word equations

The substances present at the start of a reaction are the reactants; the new substances formed are the products. A word equation names them, with an arrow that reads "produces" or "yields" and plus signs between substances. For baking soda and vinegar: sodium hydrogen carbonate + acetic acid → sodium acetate + water + carbon dioxide. The carbon dioxide is the gas you see bubbling. In the next lessons you will replace the names with formulas and balance them.

The law of conservation of mass

In the 1770s and 1780s the French chemist Antoine Lavoisier weighed reactions very carefully in sealed containers and found that the total mass never changed. This is the law of conservation of mass: in a chemical reaction, the total mass of the products equals the total mass of the reactants. The reason is that atoms are only rearranged; none are created or destroyed. The law is easy to see in a closed system, where nothing can enter or leave. Many everyday reactions happen in an open system, where gases can escape into the air or be drawn in from it, and then a balance seems to show mass appearing or disappearing.

Closed system (sealed flask)Open system (open beaker)150.0 g150.0 greactiongas staysinsideCO₂ gas escapes150.0 g148.6 greactionbeforebeforeafteraftermass before = mass afteratoms rearranged, not created or destroyedmass seems to dropnot destroyed: the gas left the system
Fig 2Left: a sealed flask on a balance has the same mass before and after a reaction. Right: an open beaker loses mass as gas escapes. The mass is not destroyed; the gas simply left the system.
Set-upWhat the balance showsExplanation
Baking soda and vinegar in a sealed bottle with a balloonNo change in massClosed system: the carbon dioxide is trapped and still weighed
Baking soda and vinegar in an open beakerMass decreasesCarbon dioxide gas escapes into the air
Steel wool burned in an open dishMass increasesOxygen from the air joins the iron to form iron oxide
Wood burned in a campfireThe ash weighs far less than the woodCarbon dioxide and water vapour float away as gases
Apparent changes in mass come from matter crossing the boundary of an open system, not from mass being created or destroyed.
Explaining a mass discrepancy
If the measured mass changes, ask what crossed the boundary. A drop in mass means a product (usually a gas) escaped. A rise in mass means a reactant (often oxygen from the air) was added without being weighed at the start. Repeat the experiment in a closed container and the masses match, within the precision of the balance.

Worked examples

Reveal one step at a time and try to beat it to the next line.

Example 1
A 2.0 g strip of magnesium burns completely in air, leaving 3.3 g of white magnesium oxide powder. What mass of oxygen reacted, and why did the mass increase?
Example 2
A beaker of vinegar plus a spoonful of baking soda has a total mass of 152.0 g before mixing. After the fizzing stops, the beaker and its contents have a mass of 150.9 g. Explain the result and find the mass of gas produced.
Example 3
Classify each change as physical or chemical, and give your evidence: (a) an ice cube melts, (b) a silver spoon turns black, (c) sugar dissolves in tea, (d) an egg is fried.

Where marks get lost

  • Treating every bubble as proof of a reaction. Boiling water bubbles too; bubbles count only when a new gas forms.
  • Saying "mass was lost" when a gas escapes from an open container. The mass left the system; it was not destroyed.
  • Forgetting that a reactant can come from the air: burning steel wool gains mass because oxygen joins the iron.
  • Mixing up reactants and products: reactants are on the left of the arrow (what you start with), products on the right (what forms).
  • Using a single clue as proof. A colour change alone, like adding food colouring, can be physical; look for several kinds of evidence.

Flashcards 8

Chemical change
Physical change
Five kinds of evidence of chemical change
Precipitate
+ 4 more

Practice

1
Which observation is the best evidence that a chemical reaction has happened?
2
A sealed plastic bag contains 85.0 g of reactants. After a reaction inside, the bag puffs up with gas. What is the total mass of the bag's contents now, in grams?
g
3
An open beaker containing an acid and a piece of chalk (calcium carbonate) has a total mass of 212.4 g. After fizzing, its mass is 209.8 g. What mass of carbon dioxide escaped, in grams to one decimal place?
g
4
A 5.0 g pad of steel wool is heated in an open dish. Afterwards its mass is 6.4 g. What mass of oxygen combined with the iron, in grams to one decimal place?
g
5
Why does the measured mass of steel wool increase when it burns in an open dish?
6
Which gas turns limewater milky?
7
Match each gas test result to the gas it identifies.
A glowing splint bursts into flame
A burning splint makes a squeaky pop
Limewater turns milky
8
Which of these is a physical change?
9
What is the general name for the substances present at the start of a chemical reaction?

Spot a mistake on this page? Let us know